No, I pointed out that a hot .357 has more kinetic energy than a .45 Colt yet the .45 Colt is a better field cartridge. That blows the 'kinetic energy is what makes any caliber good and/or effective' theory to pieces.

I will also state that nothing you shoot can tell the difference between a 1250 fps .357 load and one traveling 1500 fps. There--I kept it to one caliber, if the comparison was so offensive to you.