I voted for the Combat Magnum, since from the list there, that is the one I would most like to see available again. On the other hand, if I could get anything S&W ever made back into production, it would be the I-frame as it reached its pinnacle of development in about 1950 (before it was "improved" with a coil spring action!
)
I see all the desire to go to a big, magnum super blaster that will take on the world and assorted aliens from space with a single cylinder full of high performance, hyper expanding, monster destroyers, but the fact of the matter is that a small, easily carried gun on the person beats a big old bulky one left at home.
I'm with the old sheriff who was asked by a reporter who noticed he was carrying his old hog leg at a formal event whether he was expecting trouble. He replied, "No ma'am, if I was expecting trouble, I'dda brought my rifle." That's my story and I'm sticking to it!
Froggie