I don't know. Technically, that would presumably satisfy the definition of ammoniated. However, there's some conflicting statements out there.

In addition, S&W's manual states to never use it on *all* their guns. Is S&W really stating to not use what has to be the most popular gun solvent there is? Especially when a couple sentences before they state to stick with products meant for cleanly guns.

My thought would be they are stating to stay away from Hoppe's #9, but I'm not a chemist, metallurgist, or engineer for S&W???