JJEH, no offense taken and you have every right to your own opinion, and in this case I can agree with you. Match the weapon to your threat, get one of high quality and learn how to use it properly and to the best of your ability. Auto or revolver usually makes no difference if the shooters abilities are the same with each.

I'm not saying a revolver will not handle the situation because they have numerous times, but there is absolutely nothing wrong with a good auto in the right hands. But I do know of people that think the tactics of handling that situation would be different if they are armed with an auto instead of a revolver.