My opinion is going to vary like others. I like 357MAG, 44 MAG, 45 ACP and rimfires. Personally I like anything with a 4" barrel or bigger or a 3" depending on the model. Models 27, 29, 586, 686 and many others is what I look for. With S&W revolvers, their is too many to choose from because all of them are decent to collect. Do you like small, medium or large frame revolvers? Round or square butt? It all depends on what caliber you like to shoot and what fits best in your hand.

James