I opted for the M&P 40 FS. (waiting on a Storm Lake 9mm for plinking). I've read complaints about "snappy"/heavy recoil, but honestly I really don't think the 40 recoil is a big deal in the M&P. It is very controlable and quite accurate in fairly rapid fire. Just my opinion. Like a few other members noted, I think one should shoot the largest round he or she can handle accurately and comfortably.