All three are great guns and great calibers.....but I would strap on the 58....I have carried and shot one since 1981....carried one as a motor cop....still carry one concealed when the mood strikes me.....I shot the 41 mag in met sil. comp from 80-85, and have harvested several deer with the 41 as well....as much as I like the 44spl, and 45acp....the 41 mag is much more flexible in loading options.....I can carry my mid range load of a 220 gr SWC over a charge of Unique or go "full throttle with a JHP over a load of 2400.....all good.
Since you already have all three...just rotate them...quandary solved. Good shooting.