I know there's a lot of dislike on the principle of them, but I loved mine. It didn't interfere with anything, and held the revolver in place securely, and most importantly disappeared. All the big chunky leather and some kydex holsters cause too much of a bulge for me.

The counter argument to these is always the lack of a trigger covering, to which I reply I have my belt and pants covering the trigger, and the J frame requires such a deliberate pull I can't imagine anything actually setting the damn thing off by accident.

The only legit problem I have with it is that it clips to your pants, not the belt. If you wear the gun at or close to a belt loop, forget I said anything there won't be an issue. If you wear loose pants and wear it away from a belt loop, it does sag a bit with a steel J.

It's great for making quick trips to the store and I wouldn't hesitate to get another.