Originally Posted by Zipdog

A hard pick but I don't think you need to spend extra to get something great. Two good choices already. I do highly suggest you try the rubber Hogue Bantam grips on the 686 snub. While ugly they just feel right on that gun. The wood ones aren't made the same for the pinky. I haven't been able to find anyone who has that exact profile in wood. Usually can get them for $18.00 so not a great expense to try them out. Sounds like you might end up needing 2 pair.