For my 442 I very much like Desantis soft- tuk at 4 oclock. It has an adjustable clip for cant and height. I like mine to ride a little high and I can do this with this holster. Tighten the belt and the gun is very secure in the holster.and reholster is reasonably easy. If you are not concerned about cant adjustment or reholster, I would suggest The Holster Store .Both are very comfortable.