For me I was down to either the Ruger or the S&W. I ended up going with the S&W because I wanted the 18" barrel and the lighter weight. But the Ruger is a very good choice. If you're ok with or even prefer the 16" barrel, or if you want a piston driven gun then I'd say go with the Ruger. If you'd prefer direct gas impingement, lighter weight and a longer barrel then the S&W is the better choice.

I know this isn't much help, but honestly I don't think you can go wrong with either rifle. They're both quality products. Good luck with your decision. You'll enjoy the hell out of either rifle, I have no doubt!

__________________
- Fourth Horseman -