Well I carried a Model 60 for many years (started in 1973) and it has had a large bunch of rounds put threw it.Many of them were target rounds, but it has eaten some serious "geter done" rounds, including +P
A couple years ago I bought a NO LOCK 642 but have shot it a bit but not carried as a CCW.
I also have a older very nice Dick special I got a couple years ago. It shoots very well and as it fits a few of my J frame holsters I did carry it, that number 6 round is nice.
I just purchased a very nice older factory hammer shrouded Cobra and waiting for the legal BS to be over so I can get it out of the LGS. (NYS) That puppy is lighter than the Dick Special I might give it a try as a carry, both belt holster and pocket.
So op based on what you said, if they both looked good and the prices were decent I might just purchase both of them.
Sorry to give you a third alternate answer.
