Another vote for the Marlin 1894 and I wouldn't hesitate to look at the new manufactured versions. I think Remington had some problems at first but the last several year's production has looked pretty good to me. I have one of the newer 45-70s and it is just fine for fit and function. Another option, although not currently manufactured, is the Ruger 96 if you can find one. I like the rotary mags which provide more options for bullet type although now with Hornady's FTX plastic "flex tipped" bullet the old tube magazines are less limiting. Good luck.

Jeff
SWCA #1457