The inexpensive Uncle Mike's (now mfg'd by Blackhawk) serves me well. I have several. Previously, their size #3 fit the J-frames. In more recent mfgr, the #3 is cut a bit more tightly and the gun protrudes very slightly more from the holster. Some posters have written here that they now use the larger size #4 for the Js and they have a point.

Have never had the rig cling to the gun when drawing. At $10 or so, it's hard to go wrong.

Kaaskop49
Shield #5103