There is at least one manufacturer of mag wells for competition that stopped making them for the m&p due to too much variance in frames I would hate to cut on a frame but it sounds like it's either out of spec or on the top end. I doubt s&w will do anything since it's only interfering with a non stock part, but it maybe worth a call.

Another thought, have you tried the extension on another magazine?

Sent from my Moto G (4) using Tapatalk