I never had a "mini" semi-auto, but I did have compact autos. They were the smallest I would go, and with 9mm being the smallest caliber.

However, I was initially seduced by the D frame, which isn't a S&W. Ever since that, J frames just don't have the sex appeal to sway me.

Still, it got me away from semi-autos and branded me a revolver guy first and foremost. Although, I still keep an auto or two around for when hi-cap is needed.

As with anything regarding online discussion, everyone is different and has different tastes. Whatever works for YOU is what's important.