I like to stick with rounds that have street proven reliability. NYPD have been using the Speer Gold Dot 124+P for many many years and seem to have decent real stret shooting results. Las Vegas Metro (I believe ) issue the Federal HST 124 grain+P.
Not sure how many REAL street shootings Barnes, or corbon or Hornady have to their credit.
Stick with whats been proven in actual street shootings would be my choice