This deceased horse must be just about beaten to gritty mush by now.

As noted above, it's just the old, old, old which-is-better-revolver-or-automatic argument.

Carry what you trust and can hit with, and don't count on changing the mind of someone who picks the other category. You won't.

I'm a revolver guy in my old age, and unlikely to budge; so I won't try to shift you if you like to carry a .50AE Desert Eagle IWB. Or whatever.

__________________
Oh well, what the hell.