I have and carried both revolvers and semis. But in all honesty, I grab the revolver first- it’s the simplicity of employment and safety in carry/ holstering I prefer. Am a SS in REV, SSP( and all other semi divisions) and BUG divisions in IDPA, so am familiar with both designs.

That said, each of us needs to decide for ourself what the right tool to employ for our skill level and environment.

Carry what you are competent with and ignore the chatter.

__________________
Guns + Dogs= Bliss