I own a 12" 460 XVR , and a DE44 and a GP100 357 mag. Normally I would belly right up and suggest a 460 mag, but where your considering the 5" you need to understand that first off a 5" 460XVR is going to pack some BRUTAL recoil. Secondly the 460 XVR's ammo is VERY expensive. I really think you would be more happy with a 44 mag at this time. Maybe down the road then have another look at a 460 , but I suggest the heavier 8-3/8" barrel as it softens up some of the felt recoil.