Hi,

I going to buy a Model 69 but are unable to actually get my hands on either to compare their feel and weight, 2.75" vs 4.25", at any gun shop or gun show in the Seattle Area.

Use: I am a fly fisherman and hiker. The guns only use will be for protection from bears and other attacking critters when in the wilderness when bear spray doesn't work. Otherwise, it will sit in my gun safe. Since I fly fish and wear waders, I will carry it on my chest with a chest holster. I will practice with 44 special rounds but carry 44 mag rounds when fishing and hiking.

Question: Since its primary use will be for last-second survival, within 15 to 20 yards, what would be my best choice. The 2.75 in or 4.25 in barrel. I guess what I'm asking is which has the least amount of recoil to recover for a second shot.

Thank You for your insight
Charles