I must admit I did not like the magnas on the 58 and sold it. It was an accurate shooter though. I also did not like the Remington loads. I still maintain the 41 has less felt recoil...and to be honest physics are still physics. Most loads have been toned down to Lawyer Levels these days so neither the 41 or 44 are quite as robust recoil and velocity wise. No matter though as both are good cartridges for hunting especially. I would not hesitate to shoot an elk or another moose with either. Heck I knew a fellow in Alaska that shot his yearly moose with a 357 M-28. I must admit he shot younger ones as they were much better eating.