My 3" 686-6 + shoots as good as any of my other 686s. I didn't like the lock at first but I figure it will never change so I deal with it. I had a 2 1/2" 686-6 but it was a 6 shot. Someone wanted more then me so I sold it and never got a chance to shoot it. I paid $200. for the plus direct from S&W [long story]. I say if your not collecting and just want a good shooter then get a -6.