Many years ago, I used a Barami (original right side only) on my Model 40, with a Tyler. I found it very secure and very concealable for carry, and considered it safe. However, my fingers are a little shorter than the OP's, so I didn't like having my trigger finger forced out. The gun was definitely still usable, but not optimum. I don't use the Barami now.

__________________
Formerly Model520Fan