As a retired LEO, I carried many semi autos and revolvers over the 25 years in the business, including 1911's and a 4" 629 mountain gun. Standardized the department with the Glock .40 when they first arrived on the scene. These days however, I carry either a S&W 296 or a 329PD. For me the weight of either makes for effortless all day carry and both conceal effectively in a strong side belt holster under Hawaian shirts. Both shoot comfortably with .44 special ammo and the ability to drop a speedloader of magnums into the 329pd when in the woods is very comforting to me. Shooting them, not so pleasant but I figure I can deal with the blisters on my fingers if I ever need them. A few 44 shot loads in the pocket makes for versatility I can't get in an auto. I'll probably carry the 329 exclusively when I find the right holster. I have a DeSantis but it drags and makes for a difficult and slow draw.