Was at the range today and there were two young ladies being given private instruction on shooting. They were full of very good questions and were drilling the instructor for their moneys worth.

One of the questions was how often did the instructor unload his CC weapon. He replied every night when he arrived home as he had a weapon he used for home defense . He then put his CC weapon in his gun safe . Reloading it in the morning before leaving his home .

Driving home I thought about the questions they had asked and that one kept coming to mind.

I never unload, well not exactly true . When going to the range for practice I use a different mag and leave my home defense JHP in the mag they are in, but I do shoot the round that is chambered topping off after practice when reloading for CC. I then shoot my home defense mag about every 3-4 months and reload with fresh ammo. But between those times my CC weapon stays loaded with one chambered, Condition 1 I believe its called . And is always in a holster that has a complete trigger guard covering all of the trigger opening. If its not on my body its never more then 2-3 feet from me at all times, day or night !

How often do you unload, or don't you ?? Which one ?

I never unload my CC gun. Really not a good idea as loading and unloading can be rather dangerous from a safety standpoint.

__________________
Regards
Paul

Whitwabit:

I rarely carry a semi-auto for self defense anymore as the arthritis in my hands makes clearance drills slow and painful at best. My usual EDC consists of a pair of J-frame revolvers: a Model 38-1 and a Model 638-1 almost exclusively carried in a pair of DeSantis Nemesis pocket holsters. Sometimes, when my arthritis really flares up badly, I'll carry a Model 432PD chambered in .32 H&R Magnum, and a Seecamp in .32ACP. The Seecamp is a last ditch, very close quarters pistol (it doesn't have any sights on it).

As far as my revolvers go, I unload and reload them every time prior to holstering and carrying them. This is so I can inspect each round to make sure they look okay, and that the cylinder release and ejector rod are operating smoothly and properly. I place them in the safe fully loaded once I have returned home.

Regards,

Dave

Never, for the same reasons as Paul. Statistically, accidents, especially with semi-autos, happen while someone is manipulating the mechanism of the gun, so from that standpoint you are just inviting trouble when unloading unnecessarily. Back when I carried 1911's cocked and locked, I used to lower the hammer on a loaded chamber; in hindsight, I'm not comfortable with that idea any more either, and am glad that I switched back to mainly revolvers almost 20 years ago.

I clean & lube my main carry gun (Shield 40) and then load up with my favorite carry ammo & keep it like that until I either take it to the range or the first of each month when I unload it, break it down & give it a quick wipedown & relube.

Right now I only have one gun, my carry 642. The only time I unload it is when I'm cleaning it or engaging in dry-fire practice. I do quite a bit of dry fire practice, sometimes a minute or two of drawing practice or a full 20-30 minute session with reloading, awkward positions, etc. This is also part of my regular function check to make sure the chambers are clean and dry, the bore is clear, the extractor rod and cylinder release latch are tight, the firing pin works the way it's supposed to, etc.

It was trickier when I had a Glock 23 because I was (possibly overly) concerned about bullet setback in rounds being chambered. I pulled the slide all the way back and released it to chamber a round. Whenever I cleared the chamber the ejected round would get placed in a designated 50-round box. When the box got full of ejected cartridges I'd shoot the ammo in the box, which usually happened every few months because of dry-fire practice and removing the JHP so I could shoot my practice loads at the range.

That's one of the things I appreciate about revolvers: No setback issues. I can load/unload the gun as often as I want (in accordance with safety rules, of course).

For bottomfeeders = When it's on my body , the chamber is loaded. When it's not , it isn't .

No good all encompasing reason , but after decades of habit it is my engrained manual of arms. Same way that I always carry a SA revolver with empty chamber under hammer , even though I have a mix of transfer bar and old school guns. Uniformity of manual of arms.

But I understand the reasoning of leaving semi's loaded. If it works for you interms of manual of arms for specific gun and your methods of storing gun when off person, I won't talk you out of the practice.

The only time my EDC Sig P290 RS is unloaded is when I'm cleaning the little devil;otherwise, I always keep one in the chamber. My HD bedside handgun is a Glock 19 that remains unchambered, unless I'm carrying it holstered on my person.

I've spent many, many years hunting and shooting with pump and lever rifles and shotguns with the exposed hammer. I've carried those weapons on open chamber, empty full chamber closed, and with the use of the half, no, and full cocked so much that it is nothing. I have lowered hammers on full chambers so many times its nothing to me at all. I can't think of a time I've had a negligent discharge over laying the hammer down once. To operate a hammer and empty a chamber is so second nature I don't have any fear of it. I see no danger in it. I disarm my Browning Hi Power and 1911 all the time, and consider unloading the guns as a natural part of their operation.

So no, I can't agree that unloading an auto loading handgun to be a dangerous action. I will strongly agree there are some problems with doing it daily, namely that their will be eventual bullet pushback into the casing if the same round is rechambered over and over again, something I personally have seen and have experienced problems with, including a big problem I had with UMC 230 hollow points in .45 ACP with my 1911 and with my Thompson carbine. Although cycling the magazine often with constant reloads does help prevent magazine set, it also creates magazine wear, ever so slightly, and if you reload the chamber every day, you will manually cycle the weapon hundreds of times per year, adding some minor amount of wear to the pistol itself and its replaceable springs and parts.

I do, however, feel that for a weapon that isn't fired regularly, the obvious problem is a round stuck in chamber long enough corroding and having issues. As suggested by others, its good to unload the weapon by firing it or manually unloading it and making sure to keep track of rounds that have already been chambered. Rounds that have been loaded previous and unloaded should be placed for practice, as Continental suggests. I myself have simply gotten into the habit of leaving the carry round in the chamber and shooting it every week, even if that means following it up with a magazine of non hollow points, as it forces you to practice, as well as keep a newer, fresher round in the chamber for the following week.

Old men like Wild Bill shot their cap and ball revolvers daily to clear them of old loads. Not only did this practice keep fresh, reliable loads in constant use, but also made such men into proficient shots with constant practice. Its with this that I somewhat question the whole question that OP started this thread with, because if someone is shooting their carry weapon often enough in practice, there would be no need to constantly unload and reload the weapon, something otherwise mostly kept loaded, always in the state of readiness for potential threat, which is always. The same could be said of magazine set in some ways, not an issue if the weapon is being trained with often enough. It just seems odd to unload a combat auto pistol for the sake of reloading it, the more I think about it.

Again, as stated previous, its one reason why break action rifles, shotguns, and revolvers have another small advantage to them. Checking cylinders and open chambers is safe, easy, and does not damage the ammunition in question, something that can't be said as true with the auto loader.

I only unload when I take one of my carry guns to the range to practice and then clean. For each gun that means probably once every other month or so. And since I empty the full mag and the one in the chamber prior to going to the range, when I am done with practice and cleaning and re-load the same rounds it will likely be a different one of the rounds that ends up in the chamber. Maybe once every several months I fire the self defense ammo that is kept in the gun, replacing with new self defense ammo (as opposed to the cheaper ammo I shoot at the range).

The above only applies to the semi-auto carry gun (which I have now reduced from the three I used to rotate through to a single one, a Ruger LC9s). For my 642, my most commonly carried gun, I will remove the 5 +p rounds when I go the range, then re-load the same five after practice and cleaning.

While we're on the subject, I'll mention that normally at the range I fire between 50 and 100 rounds from my carry gun, then clean it afterwards. If I fire fewer, lets say just 10 rounds or so, I don't bother cleaning but just reload it with the self defense ammo. I know some folks will fully clean a gun if even one round is fired, and I used to be that way, but as I've gotten older I guess I have become a little less diligent about cleaning a gun that really is not in need of cleaning.

The only times I remove unfired cartridges is when I load snap caps for dry fire practice and when I pack my gun for airplane travel.

My Glock 23 is kept I the safe unloaded b/c it's never carried anymore (Gen II was my service weapon). However my M&P .380 is kept in the safe loaded, in a pocket holster w/a sticky note indicating "LOADED" It is carried from time to time and loading, unloading then reloading can be dangerous. When opening the safe the sticky note is facing me so I always know the condition of the weapon.

My 442 is never unloaded b/c it's on my person. If it is switched out for the M&P .380 (mode of dress dictates) the same sticky note goes from one pocket holster to the other in the same manner for the same reason.

__________________
Old Cop
LEO (Ret.)

I clean and lube my CCW every 3-4 weeks; BG380 pocket carry. This is the only time I unload. If I EVER get to shoot again (been months), I'll pop these Hornady CDs I've been carrying and load fresh.

__________________
I'm Proud To Be An American!

Unless I'm cleaning it the only way I unload my carry gun is through the barrel and down range. Even if I have a HD only gun I still wouldn't unload my carry gun

Yesterday, I was in my front room safe.
That's a little of everything safe with a few guns.
There are loaded guns- a 649 and a 66 2 inch laying on a shelf.
I couldn't remember how long the 66 had been loaded, so I reloaded it with 6 rounds of fresh 38 +P.

__________________
NRA LIFE MEMBER

I've never seen any advantage to unloading a duty or concealed carry pistol on a nightly basis, even if you have a different home defense weapon.

Folks will argue that if you can't safely unload and reload your weapon, you've got issues, but on the other hand a large percentage of ADs happen when someone is going through those loading and unloading evolutions, and if there is no real reason to load or unload, then it makes sense to just not do it.

As mentioned above, with semi-auto pistols you have the potential for set back of the bullet in the case, and while that is rarely the case with a single chambering cycle, repeated re-chambering increases the risk of set back eventually occurring.

----

For people who unload and reload their semi-auto pistols on a regular basis it is important that they test their carry round for susceptibly to set back, and that they rotate the top rounds in the magazine to ensure the re-chambering spread over all the rounds in the magazine, and that they eventually expend the rounds after they have been re-chambered some number of times less than the number of times where set back problems have been observed.

----

Personally, I am a big believer in the value of actually shooting your carry weapon with your carry ammo on a regular basis.

When I carry a semi-auto pistol, I load it and leave it loaded until I either clean it or shoot it with practice ammo. That means I'll unload the self defense ammo once or twice a week and after a few months with all of the rounds in the magazines being chambered a few times, I'll expend them all in live fire practice/testing. That ensures that 1) the ammo still works as expected, 2) the pistol is still reliable with the self defense ammo, and that 3) the recoil impulse and point of impact of my practice rounds do in fact accurately reflect the recoil impulse and point of impact of my self defense rounds.

When I carry a revolver, I also leave it loaded unless I am shooting it with practice ammo or cleaning it. And, even though set back is a non issue in a revolver, I will still expend my self defense ammo every few months in live fire practice/testing as I do with a semi-auto.

Once per week. As I load +1 I take the rounds which were alternately chambered for the week and put them in the bottom of the mag. When their turn comes around again I shoot that mag off at the weekly outdoor range session and start with fresh ammo.

I carry a J frame revolver and it is never unloaded. Further, it is the only firearm in my safe that is loaded. Jawge

Thanks for the many responses .

Safety is the most often cited reason and is the reason I don't unload either. I'm lucky in that I can step out my back door and unload my weapon by firing it at a steel target set up in back yard (house in country).

Although unloading should be able to be accomplished without any safety risks it is where many ND's happen even with experienced shooters. There was an incident here near where I live a few years ago . Thank fully the weapon was pointed toward the floor and the only casualty was the water heater in the basement . The gentleman it happened to was a long time hunter and shooter. So it can happen even to some of the most experienced of shooters. Just a few seconds of inattention to details and an accident can happen !

Carry condition 1, in drawer condition 2. Plenty of practice.

Note -- he told them he had a loaded gun to use at home. Being in a litigious society, (and assuming they were tender young newbies), he gave a "lawyer's answer" -- and I don't blame him. He was covering all his bases.

Try calling S&W and asking, for instance, if it's okay to use reloaded ammo in your gun -- they'll say NO -- even if the person answering your question fires thousands of reloads per year in his own S&W's.

__________________
Pisgah

Whenever I practice, dry fire or live range (I can walk out my back door and shoot). Now I use a wheel gun so there is that I suppose.

__________________
K & N S&W revolvers

I don't keep any loaded guns in my safe. When I croak I won't have control over who may go in there or how gun savvy they may be. My HD gun is always loaded if I'm present in the house. My carry guns get loaded and unloaded frequently as I often switch carry guns depending upon planned travel. Also I shoot my carry guns often.

I would like to respond to the many comments about the lack of safety in loading and unloading firearms. I would suggest that the more often guns are handled, the more proficient the handler becomes in doing so safely. Fear, inexperience and ignorance are the common causes of accidental discharges not the act of loading and unloading.

All the handguns (autos) in the safe are currently loaded & chambered, with the exception of the .22s.

HD shotgun is loaded without a shell chambered.
SxS is loaded but barrels down.
AR is loaded with a 20 round mag & chamber empty, bolt down.
All other long guns are unloaded.

Nothing changes unless I will be cleaning or dry-firing. If going to the range, the loaded gun is drawn and fired without manipulation of any kind to find out what would have happened if it had been needed (so far they've all been 100%).

Unless I'm going to the range, clean or work on it, my loaded carry gun remains holstered.
I have no reason to routinely unholster a loaded gun for safety.
It's contrary to my general observations that accidents with carry guns overwhelming occur after the gun is unholstered.

That's why I like my DA/SA with a decocker, makes the semi a little more revolver like at least for the first shot and by then you are either committed to self defense or at the range, either way the first pull is a doosie.

__________________
Back to back World War Champs.

Unless I'm shooting it I leave it be. I remove the holster with gun in "gun free zones." Joe

__________________
Wisdom chases me; I'm faster

The only time my CC pistol is unloaded, is when it's disassembled (field stripped).
Any time it's assembled, it's loaded to +1.

Every week at the range-at a target. Go through a lot of ammo that way but the practice is necessary.

I agree. I'll rotate the mags at the range, make sure they're functioning properly. The long and short guns in the safe are clear, the guns that I carry are always condition 1, whether in the safe or on my person.

My home gun is a ruger sr9. Full mag, not chambered in safe. If I need it I will rack it as I take it out.

Carry gun lc9S. In safe, no magazine in gun. When I go to carry it I chamber the round. I do rotate the rounds.

You carry your guns loaded..

I carry one bullet in my shirt pocket just in case.

I unload my gun(s) when necessary.

If the gun needs to be cleaned, I'll unload it prior to cleaning. For my carry gun, this is at least every other week if I don't shoot it. Of course, I try to shoot it every week so, it's rare that it doesn't get cleaned.

Then, if confronted by a bad guy, I'll try to unload at least two rounds worth. Of course this would include a rapid reload as well.

__________________
Freedom isn't free.

My EDC gets unloaded @ every 6 months. I shoot til empty, clean, reload repeat in 6 months or sooner as needed.

Why wouldn't you get to shoot again? Why has it been months?

__________________
Stay protected my friends.

When I took "force on force" training I got the nickname 5 Shots...because that's how many rounds I put into the perp when I had to shoot.

__________________
Stay protected my friends.

Thats what I was wondering but thought I misread something

I keep my pistols loaded, but no rounds in the chamber. I chamber a round when I holster it before carrying it. I keep my guns either in a safe or some kind of lockbox. I have lockboxes strategically placed, hidden in my house. All my lockboxes use an electronic keypad with back up key in case the batteries die.

Three contradictory statements all in one..

So you keep them unchambered, until you carry, so then what happens when the gun comes home.??

Do they go in the lock box chambered or empty?

If so how do they get to that condition..

My EDC stays loaded. The only time it is unloaded is when the mag runs empty just before cleaning.

Good grief, but some of the responses in this thread astound me.

I never unload my carry piece except when I make it a point to unload it through the barrel when I take it along with me to the range. I like to make a quick check of dependability once in a while, and I have never been disappointed.
Then I take it home for a thorough cleaning and stoke it again.

The responsibility of securing loaded weapons is whole 'nuther topic, but for the life of me I can't figure why anyone would unload a pistol every evening in order to just place it in a safe to then take it out and load it the next morning. What the hell?

I can't prove this, but I have an intuitive feeling that more people are accidently shot during the unloading and reloading of firearms than they are by a loaded gun just being transported to a safe or placed on a table.

I also can't prove this, but I also have an intuitive feeling that more sexual attacks, robberies and home invasions are repelled better with a loaded gun than by an empty gun.
I don't know why, but it just feels to me that might be the case.
Or maybe I'm just crazy. Meh.

I often carry 1911's (mostly a Defender 9mm and Ltwt. Commanders), and I have always wondered why anyone at any time would lower the hammer on a loaded chamber.
The ONLY purpose I could think of might be if someone is foolish enough to carry in ConTwo, but from a standpoint of readiness, you might as well carry in ConThree, and from that standpoint, you might as well not carry a 1911 at all. (I'm not directing this comment at you personally, Absalom, just a general statement about carrying 1911's).

A 1911 carried in ConOne is as safe if not safer than a pistol such as a Glock or SA-XD (both being very safe pistols to carry).

I always carry ConOne, and I leave in ConOne when I put it on shelf or in the safe or anywhere I want it to be available as a self-defense pistol should be.
Unloading is simple and safe; drop the mag, thumb safety off (finger no where NEAR the trigger), rack the slide, and visibly check the chamber. That's it for unloading or manipulating the hammer (with the slide).

I do agree that people who are not completely knowledgeable and confident in the workings of a 1911 should probably avoid their use.

You intuitively knew that lowering the hammer on a loaded chamber was an "uncomfortable" thing to do, and it WAS (I still don't know why you did it), so it was a good and proper thing you did that you got away from the 1911 platform when you did.

However, I would like to recommend that you revisit semi-autos, specifically the Springfield XD-S.
It's a single-stack that's a little thinner than a lot of 1911's, plus, you get a trigger that is better than a lot of revolvers, and it's just as safe as any revolver to carry as well.
My wife loves her XD's because all she wants to have to do is point and pull to stop a threat. Not even thumb safety to have to consider when she would need it.
My biggest fear of having my 1911's nearby when she needs it the most will be that she freeze and just try to pull the trigger not registering that it has a thumb safety.
I spent a full day at a range once making sure that she would know she needs to snick it off when the time comes.
Sorry to ramble on...

I carry my guns chambered. When I am not carrying them, I remove the chambered round, but I keep the magazines topped off, and inside the weapon. When not carrying there are no rounds in the chamber. When not carrying, I keep the unchambered firearms in lockboxes. If an emergency occurs and I am not carrying, I go to a lockbox, retrieve my weapon, rack the slide, and I am good to go.

I've never felt unsafe about loading or unloading a handgun, except a Grendel P-10. I may feel that way a little about tubular magazine long guns, pumps and levers. Just because everything goes through the chamber. I leave the gun in my truck loaded, never unload it unless I'm at the range. My policy is, "If you find a gun at my house, and you haven't checked it, then it's loaded."

__________________
Wayne
Torn & Frayed

So the short answer to the OP is that you unload everytime the gun comes home.

Which raises this question. Why do you unload to keep in a lock box.

Are you afraid someone will find the lock box and get your gun.

If so what is the difference chambered or not?

For me in the middle of the night I'd be lucky just to get a lock box open under stress.

I walk in circles trying to find the bathroom.

My home guns sleep under my pillow. I do wonder sometimes if I'll have a bad dream and grab my gun and shoot my way out, but it's a chance I'll take..

I try to shoot my EDC often. I run all of my mags to insure functionality so this means unloading and reloading with FMJ. I've already thoroughly tested with my defensive load, but I will usually shoot the one that was in the chamber before its rim gets chewed up by the extractor. As it is also my home defense gun it is never unloaded.

I'm not saying my way is the best way. My way is just what works for me.

My backyard is fully fenced in (6ft high wood fence, all my neighbors' yards are fenced in too in a similar way), I have motion sensor lights around my yard, my porch light and garage light stay on all night, I have a burglar alarm, and I sleep with my bedroom door locked. If someone is trying to break into my house, I have plenty of time to (from the laying position in my bed) lean over, type in my code, grab my gun, rack the slide, and protect my loved ones.

I've only ever had one incident where somebody tried to break into my house. They jiggled my garage door to try to get in, and my alarm went off. I had my pump shotgun in my hands in under 10 seconds, and I heard their car burning out in front of my house in under those 10 seconds.

I agree and, besides, my EDC is a revolver, what's the point of unloading it unless you have kids around or some other safety consideration?

The only reason I unload my home defense guns occasionally is to give the springs a break. And those guns are actually long arms - I don't keep loaded automatic pistols around my house, just revolvers.

Always loaded....Press check each morning.



.

__________________
"IN GOD WE TRUST"

Like most of here I have a number of firearms in the house, but my ready revolvers are only unloaded for cleaning after a range trip, they are reloaded as soon as I'm done cleaning them.