Value of Belgium double action Schofield copy?

Bill_in_fl

Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2012
Messages
220
Reaction score
141
Location
Hudson, Fl.
I have a chance to pick up a Belgium double action Schofield copy. Saw it last evening. Looks to be old nickel plating over numerous tiny pits on entire gun, but overall nickel covers well and looks very good. Owner says it's factory nickel, but I see nickel over small pits which makes me dubious. Hard to see most tiny pits without magnifying glass (which I used). At first glance it presents smooth nickel beautifully until carefully examined. Owner claims it was made somewhere from turn of century until 1920's.

Timing is off some but biggest problems are the hammer spring is so light I'd be concerned that it wouldn't pop a primer and the bolt doesn't rise up enough to lock the cylinder most of the time as well as cylinder has lots of play pushing both forward and rearward. Not sure of caliber because of inadequate markings. Does have Belgium proofs. Owner says he thinks it's 44/40 but I don't see how he knows for sure without markings since he hasn't shot it and doesn't seem to know that much about it. Bore is "wavy" but rifling is clearly present. Chambers look okay. Has real mother of pearl grips.

Might be something I could fix but a little hesitant having never worked on a Schofield or Belgium copy before. Researched it a bit online and it is larger than a regular S&W Schofield and most parts will not interchange with a S&W and the internals are somewhat different and parts would be extremely hard to find if at all. Probably would have to make parts if they were needed. Here's a pic I found online that looks just like it only the one I am interested in has smoother better looking nickel plating (over very tiny pits) and undamaged real mother of pearl grips.

belgian44western.jpg


I'm not interested in keeping it personally. I'd just be getting it to fix and flip. Owner is asking $300.00 Just don't want to end up with a problematic lemon Belgium copy that I can't get working due to lack of parts unless it would be worth a lot if I fixed it.

My question is, what's it worth in this condition I described, and also if it was working perfectly?



.
 
Last edited:
Billinfl - These revolvers are so ugly, yet so interesting that it is always fun to see them. I would really be hesitant to buy something that was not in perfect working order for that price. You never know until you tear into the works what is wrong and forget about finding parts.

I have a Belgium copy as well and I have actually shot a few times. It came with an imitation Bridgeport rig. Paid $150 for the gun and belt a few years ago because it was unusual, but I would never think I would get $300 out of it.
 

Attachments

  • DSCF003.jpg
    DSCF003.jpg
    218.4 KB · Views: 181
  • DSCF004.jpg
    DSCF004.jpg
    186.4 KB · Views: 323
Its more a copy of a Smith & Wesson DA Frontier or Model 3 than a Schofield. Schofields were never made in double action. The grips might be Merwin Hulbert grips or Hopkins and Allen. If not then the Belgian company did a pretty good job of replicating them.
 
Thanks for the info fellas. Another friend of mine from another forum, who is knowledgeable about these, also told me today that it wasn't worth $300.00 even if it was operating perfectly. Although I like old guns, and this one is endearingly ugly in style and interesting (like an old Webley), I think I'm going to pass on this one. Now if it was a real S&W or a 1917 that would be a different story.



.
 
Last edited:
The last one I had of these said "Shofield " on the barrel rib! I sold it to Jim Supica as an oddity to go with his real Schofields, for fifty bucks. It had Belgian proofs, and was very sloppy in it's lock up, etc. You're smart to walk away from this one! Ed.
 
I've got a weakness for these old big-bore "copies", but only at in the $50 or so price range.;) (and functioning, or nearly so...)
 
I would give the price some consideration if it was a Spanish copy by Garate Anitua and Cie or Orbea Hermanos and chambered in 455 Webley. That is to much for a Belgian. The Spaniards are infinitely superior.
 
This post is almost four years old, can anyone give an update on the value of these copies? Thanks!
 
Back
Top