About those excessive recoil reports…
I own several blow back .32 ACP and .380 ACP pistols. They include these steel frame pistols:
- A couple Walther PP pistols in .32 ACP;
- A couple Walther PPK/S pistols in .380 ACP;
- An FEG AP9S in .380 ACP (PP clone but slightly larger sized);
- An FEG APK9S in .380 ACP (PPK/S clone but slightly larger sized);
- An FEG APK7S (same as the above except in .32 ACP);
- A Beretta Model 70S (.380 ACP); and
- An RIA Baby Rock (.380 ACP).
I also own a few aluminum alloy framed pistols including;
- An FEG SMC in .380 ACP;
- A Beretta Model 81 (.32 ACP); and
- A Bersa Thunder in .380 ACP.
For comparison purposes I also own a delayed recoil locked breech Kimber Micro (.380 ACP) and a delayed roller locked breach Kimber Micro 9 in, of course, 9mm Luger and both are aluminum alloy frame pistols.
Here are my observations on them:
1) The heavier steel framed blow back pistols have less felt recoil then the aluminum alloy frame blow back pistols. That’s just simple physics and the weight of the forearm.
2) The blow back pistols in .32 ACP are very pleasant to shoot, even in an aluminum alloy frame, while the .380 ACP pistols have more felt recoil. Again that’s just physics.
3) The only one of the above pistols that has objectionable recoil is the Bersa Thunder. I’m not sure why as the FEG SMC is both smaller and lighter but is much more pleasant to shoot than the Bersa Thunder.
Bersa just seems to have gotten everything perfect to maximize .380 ACP recoil, and if it’s someone’s only experience with a blow back .380 ACP, I can see why it would put them off of the entire breed.
4) Locked breech pistols have both lighter recoil springs and lower perceived recoil, as the delayed locking mechanism spreads the recoil out over a longer period of time with lower slide velocity.
5) The Kimber Micro in .380 weighs about half as much as a PPK/s in .380 ACP, but has about the same perceived recoil.
6) The a Kimber Micro 9, despite being slightly larger and heavier than the Micro, has a lot more perceived recoil.
Clockwise from upper left: FEG AP9S; Walther PP, Walther PPK/S; and FEG APK9S.
Clockwise from upper left: Bersa Thunder; Beretta Model 70S; FEG SMC; and Walther PPK/S.
——-
The Beretta pocket pistols are in my opinion all very interesting. Beretta took the same basic design and made a large number of variants over the years in .22 LR, .32 ACP and .380 ACP and in both steel and aluminum frames, in both single and DA/SA operating systems and with a number of minor variations in safeties, magazine releases and take down levers.
All of the, are interesting and all of the ones I have owned or shot have been well made, very reliable, accurate for the type and fun to shoot. However, I suspect that’s not the case for a significant number of Beretta’s customers as they definitely started going large on some of their designs, like their Model 81, which is positively huge for a .32 ACP pistol. Similarly, some of their .380 ACP pistols are compact 9mm sized.
Top to bottom: Beretta Model 70S; Model 71; and Model 81.