.40 Shield sent to S&W customer service

emory

Member
Joined
Oct 30, 2013
Messages
81
Reaction score
75
Location
New Orleans
Wanted to share with you guys my recent experience with S&W customer service:

6/11 – I was at my local indoor range, 40rds deep into a 50rd box of Federal 180gr FMJs when I got a squib load: Pistol went "piff", action failed to cycle, no hole in the paper. I dropped the mag, ejected the case, stripped the pistol, and saw the bullet stuck in the barrel. The gunsmith on site knocked it out with a few whacks and a brass punch. I decided to play it safe and take it home and inspect it rather than finish my session. I'm glad I did. The frame was fine, but there was a ring around the bore about an inch shy of the crown that would not go away even with a very vigorous brushing. This mark was hair thin, but visible to the naked eye, and I could feel it with the tip of a toothpick. Although a crack seemed unlikely, I decided to send it in to S&W.

6/13 – I called S&W customer service and explained my problem. The rep explained that he couldn't give me a shipping label because it wasn't a warranty issue, but to follow the instructions on S&W's website and send the pistol in. He said they would check it out and if the barrel was cracked, they would bill me for a new one. The part runs about $75.

6/30 – I wrote them a brief letter explaining what happened and asked them to check the bore for cracks. I included my credit card info and told them to bill me for parts and labor and to go ahead and replace the recoil spring since I had 1,600 rounds on the original. I included the letter, gun, and magazine, as well as the removed bullet and empty case into a box and sent it UPS to the customer service address.

7/3 – UPS tracking confirms delivery at S&W.

7/9 – I called customer service to make sure they got the box and to get a status report. They looked it up by serial number and said it was sent to repair on 7/7. (7/4 was a holiday) I am told to expect about three weeks, so I tell myself that I am not going to call until 7/28.

7/22 – I come home from work and there is a FedEx box waiting for me. The shipping label was printed on the 18th. They replaced the barrel, included a new recoil spring, cleaned and lubed the gun, and didn't charge me a penny. They did keep the bullet.

So in summary: I called customer service twice. I never had to wait on hold. The people I spoke to were polite, knowledgeable, and they sounded American! They gave me a very reasonable estimate of how long I should expect for a repair and then they beat their own estimate by a week. They replaced damaged parts and provided an extra part free of charge, despite my stated intention to pay for a problem that was clearly caused by the ammunition.

I am very, very pleased with S&W customer service.

I have to admit that I was dying to post about this while I was waiting to get it back, but for some reason I decided to be patient and see how it all shook out first. So that's how it went. Here's some pics of the squib:
SNl7PYHl.jpg

1USZ87Cl.jpg

eg3VRdkl.jpg
 
Register to hide this ad
Sounds like a happy ending.

So.. it's obvious they have barrels... would looooove to know why they won't sell them any more :(
 
Did you happen to contact Federal with the lot number and tell them what happened?
 
OP, have you contacted Federal Ammuntion? Their faulty ammunition caused this. I had some Wolf ammo that damaged an SKS of mine, and I contacted the company about it; Wolf 'bought back' the rest of the ammo I had from that lot and paid for the replacement parts. (I wanted to do the work.)

Anyway, drop a line to Federal, worse that can happen is your out a few minutes of your time, best case they might foot the bill!
 
I find many companies give a longer repair time than it actually takes to make the customer happy when the gun is back in 2 weeks instead of the predicted 3. Glad it worked out for the OP, & that there was no charge. GARY
 
I had an issue with a Federal HST bought new at a local gun store. One of the rounds had the "lip" curl from improper seating.
Federal couldn't have handled it any better.

They offered me a small check to reimburse me for my time, they wanted the round...and I obliged. I just asked for a shirt instead.. They wouldn't take "No" for an answer.

Just an FYI...call Federal, they'll do you right.

Glad to hear SW CS did you right.
 
As a new Shield 40 owner, hearing about yet another issue about the Shield 40 is concerning, but hearing about how s&w cs handled the issue is comforting... Thanks for the post...
 
LOL... This was not an 'Issue' with the Shield40... It was Clearly an Ammo issue. The Shield40 simply happened to be the pistol firing the defective ammo. This could have been ANY brand's .40 pistol.
Since it was ammo related and not pistol parts/workmanship related, I too am pleased to hear that S&W CS did the right thing with no charge to the owner.

And yes... Many CS departments would rather give the owners an exaggerated expected wait period, just in case they run into snags. Many times the actual turn-around time is less than the projected estimate. Not Always, but many times. :)

And Kudos to the OP for not getting bent all out of shape with S&W's request to have the whole pistol sent in and not getting an RSA ticket. Many would have argued/whined about that aspect.
 
Last edited:
I disagree. If this is a ammo issue why didnt s&w make the owner pay for the parts and treat it like the customers that have the kabooms?
 
LOL... This was not an 'Issue' with the Shield40... It was Clearly an Ammo issue. The Shield40 simply happened to be the pistol firing the defective ammo. This could have been ANY brand's .40 pistol.
Since it was ammo related and not pistol parts/workmanship related, I too am pleased to hear that S&W CS did the right thing with no charge to the owner.

And yes... Many CS departments would rather give the owners an exaggerated expected wait period, just in case they run into snags. Many times the actual turn-around time is less than the projected estimate. Not Always, but many times. :)

And Kudos to the OP for not getting bent all out of shape with S&W's request to have the whole pistol sent in and not getting an RSA ticket. Many would have argued/whined about that aspect.

Whether this or the kabooms are an ammo issue or not, it seems like these "ammo" issues are happening more frequently with the Shield 40 for what ever reason. It's still nice to know that if I have an "ammo issue", s&w is willing pay and take a lost for something that wasn't their fault or covered under warranty especially when they are known not to. They'll usually will offer you a small discount on a new firearm, or make you pay for repairs.
 
Last edited:
Wow - that is like blaming the Ford because you bought bad gas from Shell and it damaged your vehicle. I wouldn't expect Ford to pay for it. If they did, I would be pleased and happy about it. Not point out every issue anyone has ever had with a Ford.

Gratitude people. Look it up.
 
Did you happen to contact Federal with the lot number and tell them what happened?

I did contact Federal just to let them know. I did not ask for a response, but I would like to think that they would follow up. They havent so far. I will post about it when/if they do.

Sadly, I have 600rds of the same exact ammo and I am hesitant to shoot any. I know that, stastically speaking, I have nothing to fear. It seems stupid to go buy more target ammo when I have so much already. Maybe I will go shoot up all my good hollow points. :D
 
Sadly, I have 600rds of the same exact ammo and I am hesitant to shoot any.
Is all the ammo from the same lot, or were they purchased a few boxes at a time.
Check the Lot numbers and if they ARE all from the same lot, it may be worth a follow-up email to Federal and ask about a swap-out (buy-back). If they're NOT from the same lot, just don't shoot any more from the lot that had the squib and ask about a swap/buy for just those remaining rounds. For safety sake, they MAY be very responsive to your request.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top