long----sorry!
As a long time gearhead and longtime member of a couple of Corvette forums, just let me say this subject comes up often for discussion. Think of it as the 9mm VS .45 of the car guys!
Granted Top Tear gas is supposed to have a superior additive package. Does it all time really depends on what happens at the terminal that dispenses gas to the tanker trucks. Funny things have been known to happen, as lots of money is involved use your common sense.
Where I now live we have off brands, getting what they call top tier means I fill up when 25 miles or farther from my house.
On my 7th Corvette and octane weather some people on here want to hear it or not is important for a lot of vehicles. Many high performance engines need it, most all supercharged engines need it (course a supercharged engine most times is a high performance)
Every Vette I ever owned and some of my daily drivers need it to run right. Thanks to all the computers in a modern vehicle a vehicle will run ok on low octane gas. The computer will lower timing to compensate (that protects the engine from spark knock AKA pinging) what else also happens is that timing drop also lowers you available HP and also gives you lower fuel economy. FWIW this same things happen when you put in ethanol gas, lower power and worse mileage. As a Vette driver I want every horse to pull its best and really do not give a fecal material about mileage.
As stated before there are additives that can be used for certain reasons. My biggest reason to use additives is putting a vehicle to bed for 6 months due to bad winters. Every few tankful’s I do use Techron as my Vette has a direct injected engine and that type of injection is well known to complain about fuel.I started using that in my 98 Vette due to well known problems that model had!
I also used it in my other Vettes and on occasion in my DD vehicles. Yes Techron is available in some gases but we do not have that gas up here, so I put it in myself. Most all big box stores sell it!
For winter hibernation of my Vette and in my 2 stroke mixtures and emergency stored gas I do put in a good stabilizer product to lengthen the storage time as modern gasses go bad much faster than 20 years ago, top tier or not!