Sounds a bit like cilantro - some love it, some think it tastes like soap. Glad you were able to get a refund.
chief38,
You are not alone, I find the smell of Ballistol to be a cross between old long lost mildewed sweaty socks, stagnant pond scum water with a little moldy black licorice mixed in. I stocked & sold a bunch of it to the black powder shooters, but I am convinced most of them have lost their sense of smell from their use of black powder anyway.
For over 30+ years, I've had great luck using G96 Gun Treatment on all my firearms, magazines and anything else metallic that needs to be protected from corrosion. At least to me, the smell is very pleasant and my ex never complained (at least not about the G96 smell).
Never smelled Ballistol. However, I do not like the smell of CLP. Hoppes #9 is fine to me and so is Rem Oil.
Rosewood
you guys should all try Gunzilla. You can get it on Amazon. I have been using it for several years and really like it. It has a pleasant smell and cleans well. My wife always hated the smell of Hope's when I was cleaning my guns but she never even notices Gunzilla. It is a CLP.
I use Break-free CLP (if you're talking about that one) and to me is really does not smell at all - or so little I don'r even notice.
I was talked into buying a bottle of Ballistol about 20 years ago. I still have it, and you can guess why. Have tried giving it away and no takers..........
My wife LOVES the smell of traditional Hoppes #9. She says I should wear it as cologne.![]()
There's a lot of snake oil out there and I've tried most of it at one time or another. My policy now is that I only use products that have a national stock number. If it can keep a M249 running in the desert or the Arctic, there's a good chance that it will get me through my day at the range. I was a break free user for a long time until a friend of mine who did a couple of tours in Afghanistan turned me on to M-Pro7. That's pretty much all I use now. Their gun cleaner works really well and there is very little smell. One thing you do not want to ever try is Frog Lube. I thought I had found THE gun lube but that stuff is the devils sperm. I had a 1911 that I had applied it to and it seemed great. Very slippery and dry. In the middle of an IDPA match the gun started to slow down and something that resembled maple syrup started oozing out of everywhere. Shortly after, the gun seized up. What a project cleaning it up! I ended up throwing out about $100 worth of the stuff. Do yourself a favor, DON'T USE IT!!!