Warm welcome to the OP. Assuming field use, or possibly open carry in an automobile or on 4wheeler, I have found that top break holsters are much quicker and easier to use than the ones with the leather strap, let alone the twisted thong around the hammer for retention.
Though I don’t have it by El Paso, their topbreak, lined holster, in neutral cant would work for me (have similar). Of course, there literally dozens of choices.
Hope you get some satisfaction in searching - and perhaps wind up unlike many of us who have half a bushel basket+ full of holsters that aren’t “quite right “. All best.