Recent content by fullthrottle

The only reason I'd discount the 686 and other S&W models chambered in .357 is price. I know the 686 is a great revolver due to what I've read and heard and my experience renting one for a day at a gun range. But price is a major factor in my search, and if the 64 is an effective, reliable...

Wow, thanks for all of the helpful replies. The vibe I'm getting is that a 64 would be an excellent first revolver purchase, and the 686 may not be necessary for my needs at this time. That would save me a couple hundred dollars. I'm sure that there are people out there that believe a .38...

This may be heading towards a caliber debate, but I've spoken to a handful of people that own revolvers, including a couple gunsmiths, and I'm hearing different things. Some say the .38 is just fine for defense, but others say I'd need a .357 if I'm serious about it. One even hinted a .38...

I don't see much, if any, discussion about this revolver on this forum. I'm debating between the 64 (which is less expensive but doesn't have the versatility to shoot .357 Magnum) or the 686. Both in four-inch barrels. Would the 64 be a good buy for home defense? Or would it more prudent to...

As someone who will be buying a new S&W 686P in a few weeks, this is both good news and upsetting. I'm glad their customer service is quick and thorough, but what bothers me are the numerous posts about people having to send their firearms back for repair. Seems more common than it should be...

So it's like dating?

Yes, the 642's retail price is what drew to me that model initially. But, as was said, it probably doesn't fit my need. The 60 and the 686 two of you recommended both have heftier price tags, but if they are indeed much less challenging to shoot well (and shoot often) than a J frame, then I...

I appreciate the suggestions to look at other models. However, I am adamant about purchasing a new revolver, not used. Thanks

Every reply has been helpful, but this one especially so. Thanks very much. It looks like the 60 is the model for me. Any other information you guys are willing to share about the 60 would be greatly appreciated.

Hey everybody, Please note that I have searched this forum and similar ones for information regarding my questions. I'm an inexperienced handgun shooter looking for a "nightstand gun" for home defense. In doing research, I've decided that a new, high quality revolver capable of double action...