The J-Frame wins over a compact semi-auto
In my mind the J-Frame wins hands down over a compact semi-auto. The J-Frame is much less likely to have a negligent discharge than a the small semi-auto. You never have to worry if a round is chambered or a round jams with a J-Frame or has a safety...
S&W 686 v. Colt Python
In the 1980's my EDC was a Colt Python 2.5" Nickel. I put it away when Glock came on the scene (now I carry an M&P.) It cost me almost $700 back then for the Colt. I bought a S&W 686 6" in 1995 and then a S&W 686 4" in 2010. To me there is NO COMPARISON. They each...
As alternatives to the Bodyguard 38. look at the S&W:
Model 638CT - $699.00 MSRP, which I really like and have had for years serving as my EDC. (Product: Model 638CT)
or the:
638 LaserMax - $539 MSRP, but I do not care for the way S&W mounted the laser. Product: Model 638 LaserMax