So after ordering a set of current production S&W Magnas and marveling at their incredibly poor fit, I'm looking for alternatives.

Eagle Grips makes a version, but I'd rather hear from those who have tried them before throwing another $10 away on shipping in the hope they will fit better than the S&W version.

Any recommendations?

What model gun (and what era) are your trying to find Magnas for?

The Magnas are for a 28-2 and a 27-2, both early seventies N serial number guns.

Have you considered putting original, 70's Factory Magnas back on them?

Yeah, you could probably score an original set in the classified section pretty quick.