cleaning my nickel Model 19

stevieboy

Member
Joined
Apr 27, 2008
Messages
1,450
Reaction score
40
Location
Tucson, Arizona
I am the very happy owner of a nickel Model 19 that I purchased a few weeks ago. My question is about cleaning. I really hate to see carbon build up on this gun's shiny surfaces, particularly on the cylinder face. I'd like to keep the gun looking pristine but, at the same time, I don't want to erode the nickel plating.

I have a routine that works well for removing burnt on carbon from my stainless revolvers. I first brush the surface vigorously with a bronze brush in order to loosen up or knock off as much of the gunk as possible. I follow that with vigorous rubbing with a lead removal cloth (Birchfield Casey) until the surface comes up clean.

I'm very reluctant to try this technique with my nickel gun. First, I'm afraid that brushing the surface with a bronze brush will erode and scratch the nickel. Second, I'm concerned about rubbing the gun down with a lead removal cloth. The Birchfield Casey cloth is not rated as safe for blued surfaces. The warnings on the package label do not speak about cleaning nickeled guns. Nonetheless, I'm a bit nervous about rubbing a plated surface with a cloth that has abrasives and harsh chemicals embedded into it.

So, what do you recommend. And, yes, a lot of people would call me compulsive -- particularly about keeping the cylinder face clean -- and would warn me that I'm damaging the gun by cleaning it too often. I'm ready for that. Who I want to hear from are the people who are fanatics about keeping their guns spotless. How do you pull that off with a nickel gun?
 
Register to hide this ad
I would recommend against the bronze brush or any other harsh abrasive. The lead removal cloth is safe for nickel; I use Break Free and this to remove the really stubborn cylinder face deposits. There is a previous thread about this where someone stated the lead removal cloth could erode the cylinder face enough to increase the barrel/cylinder gap, but to my thinking if the nickel plating doesn't seem affected I'm probably not getting into the steel.

Hope this is helpful, and try to spend more time shooting than cleaning :) .
 
I use the BC lead remover cloth own my nickle guns and it works great.Can't see where it's ever caused any damage to the finish.
 
For the few nickel guns I've owned through the years (not many), I've used Flitz to polish the plating and remove carbon deposits. It is a light abrasive and I don't think it has harsh chemicals.

Just one man's opinion.
 
I use Mother's Mag Wheel Polish and it has restored my nickle gun to pristine condition.
 
I have used a bunch of stuff, the best thing I've found is scrape with a brand new utility knife blade held as flat to the surface as you can get it. Then lightly use a lead removal cloth followed by Mother's chrome polish.
 
Back
Top