Not sure if this is the right place but here goes. I inherited a S&W 357 Highway Patrolman model 28-2 revolver from a family member that passed away and I'm trying to determine its worth. It has a serial number N17x805. I put x in the 4th place because I couldn't determine if it was a 9 or 0. It is in very good condition and looks like it has not been fired often. If you guys can help me out with this I would appreciate it.

Those go close to $1000 here (NM) in near-new condition with the box.

$1k is about right for asking price where I shop too. I looked at two four inch ones today, no box/papers, although with correct grips and original finish showing little wear. Both were priced at $999; probably a little negotiation room in that price. Six inch versions might be $100 or so less. It wasn't all that long ago that you could get all the nice ones you wanted for $500 each but those days are gone.

Jeff
SWCA #1457

Old Smiths are only going up.

__________________
No baby we aint

Hard to put a value on it without seeing it. Around here, 4 inch guns in 90% condition go for between 900 and 1100. Lower the condition the lower the value. Even in poor condition it would probably be worth 4 bills. As stated, 6 inch guns are slightly lower.

__________________
Even older, even crankier....

I have seen them going for $1400 with box and papers for a very nice one here in CA. Depending on barrel length and condition $1k, maybe plus, is not unreasonable.

Photographs would greatly increase the precision of the estimated value...

Attached Images

IMG_4022.jpg (113.6 KB, 33 views)

Welcome to the Forum! The Highway Patrolman (aka pre-Model 28) and Model 28 revolvers (S&W started using model numbers in 1957) are very popular here. The s/n you provided dates your revolver to 1973. You didn't mention if it was has a 4" or 6" barrel...this often affects the value. 4" bbl. HPs tend to bring a little more money. If you have the original wooden magna stocks on the revolver and the original box and tools, those also affect the value. All of my 28-2s are a little bit later than yours (1974-77) and most wear magna stocks, not the larger target stocks. In the condition that you described and without photos, I would think that your revolver would be in the range of $900-$1000. You inherited a nice revolver that shoots well and is built like a tank. Enjoy!

Attached Images

IMG_0006.jpg (61.2 KB, 19 views)

Some free advice ... Don't sell it !
Chances are you will never lay your hands on another .
I would keep it in the family , I would shoot it in honor of the family member it belonged to , and pass it down when you "retire" .

The money you get from a sale will soon be spent and forgotten ...
and you wind up with a lifetime of regret .
Trust me on this ... I've seen it happen so many times .
Gary

__________________
Certified Cajun
NRA Member

I agree with gwpercle.
It is a heritage piece, keep it in memory of the deceased.
Then in time, you can pass it on. I have 2 Dan Wesson revolvers left by the NRA training coach who I co-instructed with. I'll be passing them on.