Wondering if folks here can offer any thoughts or guidance on the relative merits or trade-offs between a S&W Model 17-8 in .22lr 10 rounds capacity) and the latest Model 617 in .22lr (10 rounds capacity). I’m in the market for a .22lr revolver for target practice/plinking, and was all set to get a 617 when I saw the old 17-8 on offer (used but in excellent condition). The 17-8 is around $1100 the 617 is available for around $700.

Thoughts?

If you just want a great S&W .22 revolver for "practice/plinking" I'd buy a current model 617. If you're planning to build a collection then the 17-8 might be your choice as they're not seen very often. If all you want is one to shoot that will be reliable and accurate go with the 617.

Jeff
SWCA #1457

Accuracy and reliability and function will be no difference between either the 17-8 or 617. Ease of keeping clean the 617 is better, less likely to show noticeable wear, the 617 would be better. To me, the classier is the 17. It is just a matter of personal choice otherwise.

__________________
H Richard
SWCA1967 SWHF244

The 617 would be my choice also for the use you want, I have 3 of them and I have yet to see a 17 in a ten shot at the guns shops I frequent, that's why the extra cost, more rare. I like both 4 and 6 inch models but the 4 inch has better balance and the 4 inch seems to be harder to find also.