SW9VE vs Ruger P95 for home defense

Joined
Jul 21, 2013
Messages
4
Reaction score
1
I mistyped the title. It should be the SD9VE. Looking to buy an inexpensive 9mm for home defense and glove box. I may carry once in a while, but not often. I have trimmed my list to these two guns. What are your thoughts? Any other guns that I should consider? I am fairly new to firearms.
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
I have a sw9ve that I use for home defense and trust it completely. I have lots of other guns I could use but I use the sigma. It has a safe HD trigger and no safety. I do not have a
P95 but I have other Rugers and I would trust any of them also.
You can't go wrong with either. Try to shoot both and go with the one that feels right for you.Welcome aboard BTW.
 
I've owned both...but first, what is your budget? Is price the reason you're considering these two guns? If not, there are some other choices to consider, but they cost more. Not a lot more, but up to around $500 (more or less) such as a M&P 9, a SR9, and so on.

As for these two guns...instead of the SW9VE, I would get the SD9VE. They are very similar, but the SD has a slightly better trigger. Also, if the rail matters to you, the SD9VE has a standard rail, and you'll need an adapter for the SW (if I remember correctly.) Academy Sports has them listed for $319 on their website. These are very solid guns and reliable guns, and there are a lot of threads here about them, their function, etc. One of my favorite things about this gun is that you can easily take out the striker and clean out the channel...no pins to knock out. The trigger on this gun, even though better than the SW, is still pretty heavy...about 8 pounds...but mine is smooth. Some people modify the fire control group to make the pull lighter, but I don't find it so hard to manage that I need to do that. It's not designed as a range/target gun...and the long, heavy trigger pull acts as a safety feature.

The Ruger P95 is a DA/SA pistol with a safety/decocker. I just bought one recently (test fire date 5/2013) and the DA trigger is better than I remember the older ones being, but it's still pretty heavy and long. The SA trigger was nice. The P95 is a pretty big gun, and may be more difficult to conceal, depending on your body size and style of dress. It's a very solid and reliable gun, and very soft shooting because of its size and weight. This gun is also unique for a DA/SA pistol, because you can fairly easily break it down and take out the firing pin for cleaning...the disassembly is a little more complex than on the SD, but you don't have to knock out pins to do it.

Both guns will do a very competent job. Good luck!
 
I just swapped my p95 for the SD9VE. there was nothing wrong with the 95 but it was a little too big for me and the quality control at Ruger has recently become an issue.
If you haven't noticed the rugers, take a look at the trigger guards on them. Mine looked like they used a cheese grater on it to remove the mold marks etc. It was totally unacceptable to me. I even went so far as to inspect all the SR's at my LGS and they were all the same. Bad sanding marks on them. Real bad! i just couldnt get past it.
 
I mistyped the title. It should be the SD9VE. Looking to buy an inexpensive 9mm for home defense and glove box. I may carry once in a while, but not often. I have trimmed my list to these two guns. What are your thoughts? Any other guns that I should consider? I am fairly new to firearms.

My first thought is that you better check the size of your glovebox. Depending on the kind of vehicle you drive, neither gun may fit.

Either pistol you mention will serve you well. In the same price range, and with a superior trigger action, is the new Walther PPX M1, a 16 shot 9mm with a tenifer treated slide and barrel and a hammer fired action with a constant trigger action (same short, light trigger pull for each shot).
 
Back
Top