SW22 takedown screw loose? Check this...

AlwaysArmed

Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2015
Messages
192
Reaction score
203
I keep hearing reports of the SW22 Victory takedown screw coming loose. In the world of fasteners such as socket head cap screws, the stretch of the fastener is what holds it fast (fast = fastener. Get it?).
Therefore, it stands to reason that if the fastener is coming loose, it has not or can not stretch.
Has not means it hasn't been stretched enough to hold it fast. Solution- Tighten the screw more. I'm going to 40 in./lbs. with my F.A.T. Wrench and I almost can't get the screw loose when I clean the pistol.
Can not means no matter how tight you torque the screw it will not hold its stretch. Allowing the screw to come loose. Solution- Find what is preventing the fastener from working properly.

After studying my pistol, I have a couple of items that may lead to the looseness of the cap screw in some guns. Let's see if we can find things wrong.

I would check two things first...
1- Make sure the shoulder of the socket head cap screw is flat and at a right angle to the threads of the screw. Check for contact marks across the face of the cap shoulder.

My camera doesn't make good close up pics but maybe you can see mine in the image of the cap screw here.

2- Make sure the surface that the shoulder of the cap screw sits against is flat and square. Look at the shoulder inside the hole where the takedown screw goes into and make sure it is flat and not rounded off. Mine has a matte finish like it has been bead blasted. I'd say if you have a shiny ring here there is improper contact with the screw and screw stretch (tightness) can't be achieved.

Just an idea. Hope this helps lead to a solution.
And a couple more things...

I believe this socket head cap screw is a #12 short head fastener. Very uncommon. The torque chart says it should be tightened to 65 in./lbs.

If you want to use blue Loctite on your screw (I don't recommend it) you must use primer on stainless steel.

I would also not recommend any lock washers or star washers. These things can not work until the screw comes loose and then the lock washer can dig in (aint gonna happen on stainless steel and a grade 8 screw). Think about it.
 

Attachments

  • Screw.jpg
    Screw.jpg
    30.1 KB · Views: 127
  • Shoulder.jpg
    Shoulder.jpg
    33.7 KB · Views: 137
What about a drop of oil on the screw thread?

That will reduce friction and allow the fastener to stretch more with the same torque applied than with a dry thread.
It won't help if the fastener isn't working properly.
 
I took mine apart to clean and lube it before I fired it for the first time. I didn't tighten the takedown screw tight enough, and it came loose after a box or two. After that I've tightened it pretty tight. I haven't used a torque wrench yet, but I did mark the screw and frame so that I'm doing it consistently. It hasn't come loose again after that. I will say, though, that I don't like tightening it as much as I have been. I fear wearing these parts out, especially the internal flats in the screw where the Allen wrench fits.
 
I called S&W a few minutes ago. The tech. said the torque spec was 20 in. lbs, don't oil or lube the screw, or any thing else on the screw.
 
Wouldn't a star washer solve this issue? Friction would take over for the stretch factor.
 
Different Information On Different Days

I called S&W a few minutes ago. The tech. said the torque spec was 20 in. lbs, don't oil or lube the screw, or any thing else on the screw.

It's interesting - you got a better informed tech than I did. I called them on 03/04 to specifically ask what the proper torque was for the takedown screw. The person with whom I spoke told me that there is NO TORQUE SPEC for tightening this allen screw when reassembling the pistol. He told me that they recommend just tightening the takedown screw until things are snug. I asked about using LocTite on the threads and he said that it wasn't needed.

I have no idea what torque I used when a reassembled my pistol yesterday but I did use the purple LocTite on the threads. I fired two hundred more rounds through the pistol today with no loosening of the takedown screw. After I clean it tonight I will use this torque spec to tighten it back down again and I will still use the purple LocTite.

Thanks for finding out the torque spec information.
 
Could be they were getting so many request for a torque value, they had their engineers come up with one, especially if people stripping screws. I personally am using 30, down from 35. I think my next range trip I'll try 20. Also, think I'll email tech support just to see what they say. Dave
 
It's interesting - you got a better informed tech than I did. I called them on 03/04 to specifically ask what the proper torque was for the takedown screw. The person with whom I spoke told me that there is NO TORQUE SPEC for tightening this allen screw when reassembling the pistol. He told me that they recommend just tightening the takedown screw until things are snug. I asked about using LocTite on the threads and he said that it wasn't needed.

I have no idea what torque I used when a reassembled my pistol yesterday but I did use the purple LocTite on the threads. I fired two hundred more rounds through the pistol today with no loosening of the takedown screw. After I clean it tonight I will use this torque spec to tighten it back down again and I will still use the purple LocTite.

Thanks for finding out the torque spec information.

Yikes! White text isn't readable !
 
Back
Top