Originally posted by Grayfox:
I beleieve that Kimber makes a good 1911, but its also highly over rated.
Absolutely.
The early Kimbers were nicely made. The newer ones after the move, and the series II (idiotic move with the rinky dink firing pin safety they use) are nowhere near the same quality of gun.
If you want the best production 1911 value it's probably a Les Baer Premier II (no, I don't own one). S&W 1911s aren't bad, like Kimber, but they aren't all that special and are somewhat overpriced. They're higher end assembly line guns, but assembly line guns, just the same.
For under $1000 I can buy a hand fit (meaning important stuff like the frame/slide) STI and have customer service, should it be necessary, that puts S&W to shame (and pretty much everybody else too). Their bargain basement ($600 or so) Spartan is also hand fit, but uses a hand fit frame and slide from the Phillipines (like many, many other companies even though you don't know it).
If STI didn't make 1911s at the price point they do, a Springfield Armory would be my next choice....they have 1911s figured out.
Kimber, S&W, Taurus, and a few others would never be on my purchase list because other companies offer more for less. R,