1905 at the Salem, VA Gunshow

VaRecon

Member
Joined
May 14, 2011
Messages
649
Reaction score
96
Location
Elliston, VA
To begin, I wasn't able to acquire the gun in this story because right now it's just not feasible. If it is still there tomorrow I will be sure to get some pictures.
However I was hoping to share the story and see if you guys could tell me more about the gun in question. With the assault rifle ban back in the news the show was bound to be packed, and it was. Black rifles being the least of my concern, I went to sell a Thompson Center Hot Shot and trade in some brass for ammo to run through the N frame this week. As I was leaving, a model 1905 caught my eye and the older gentleman selling it noticed pretty quickly. Being at best a novice when it comes to Smith's from this era I asked him about the frame size which appeared close to an N-frame. He didn't know but the grips were notched for ambi grip and appeared quite old but since I was not sure if they were N-frame sized or not I asked if he would indulge my curiosity and let me remove them for closer inspection. He did and they appeared (to my untrained eye) smaller then the modern grip of my model 27. We got to talking though and he said the price, at 650, was high but it wasn't one he really planned to sell. The gun had a pretty good finish with no real pitting but the nice aged look that comes with a revolver that was well used and well cared for. The original owner had removed the front sight post but the bluing was intact where it had been. After a few minutes of carrying on I decided I had best let him attend to a customer with cash in hand but he thanked me for the interest, told me I was welcome anytime and said it was nice to see a younger guy who could appreciate the workmanship of generations past. Despite the enormous crowd, having to butt shoulders to take each step, and the sweltering temperature from a heater turned too high and left on too long the old codger taking a few minutes of his time to indulge my interest made the trip to the gunshow easily worthwhile.
 
Register to hide this ad
Well said, VaRecon. There are some sharpies out there, but in general the gun loving community is a good bunch of people.

From a gunlover just up the road from Elliston.
 
VaRecon, I got to the Salem CC about 9:30 or so and the crowd at the entry was shoulder to shoulder - you couldn't even tell if there was a line there or just a mob. I turned around and went to gun stores in the Roanoke Valley area. Found most of the small stuff I had planned on picking up at this show at one or another of them! :D

Froggie
 
I'm not going to go back today, I would just drool over the gun again.
I was there yesterday from about 12 to 1:45, it took me about an hour and a half to circle the place and another fifteen minutes talking to the gentleman.
If anyone goes today it is certainly one you should check out, he was set up across from Trader Jerry's to the left.
 
I can not think of any Model 1905 that would be worth anywhere near $650 that had the front sight removed. These sights were forged with the barrel and any replacement could never be brought back to "original". As you say there was a "pretty good finish with no real pitting but the nice aged look that comes with a revolver that was well used and well cared for." This to me means a $250 gun. You can buy these at online auctions every day for under $300 for a great shooter grade gun. BTW, the Model 1905 was a K frame revolver, which is smaller than the N frame and came with either a round butt or square butt configuration. The early round butts are properly named Model 1902 and the square butts were all Model 1905.

You did the right thing by passing on this one.
 
Thanks for the information glowe. As I said I don't believe the guy really planned to sell it but it was overall nice to get to hold an older model that I had never seen in person. Do you by chance know how the K frame handled that beast? I'm completely green on the available calibers in this model but the one I saw was in 45 lc.
 
Back
Top