.357 pricing=crazy money?

Joined
Jun 23, 2007
Messages
5,245
Reaction score
30,550
Location
Missouri
I am finding no .357 Smiths at local gun stores for what I would come near paying anymore. Most run north of 8 bills. Yes, I know that somebody out there just bought an anib unfired 586 for $300 and actually added money to the offer because they felt sorry for the poor sucker...er...I mean seller. But are average prices where you live running 800 bucks? Any caliber above .38 just seems like it is marked at crazy money prices.

Sent from my Samsung "Smarter Than Me Phone" via tapatalk
 
Register to hide this ad
As the price of new ones continues to go up and up, the price of used ones follow. "A rising tide lifts all ships."
 
I wonder if a posting in WTB forum for a $___.__ shooter grade .357 would get you something you could be happy with. It couldn't hurt to try.

I agree. For the most part, I would much rather deal with the members on the forum. I have in the past and never had a bad experience. I have gained much knowledge here too.

When I first starting looking at gun stores though, as a new guy, I was incredibly fortunate. With limited knowledge I never bought a lemon...and I never got shafted on price. Didn't know that at the time, but in hindsight, I came out pretty good. I sure wouldn't want to be that same guy walking into a gun store today. A new guy with a limited budget could be wrecked for good on his first purchase if he got it wrong. No margin for error.

Sent from my Samsung "Smarter Than Me Phone" via tapatalk
 
.357 Magnum prices have gone NUTS!!!

Four weeks ago I paid $1,200.00 (thanks Lee) for a VERY NICE 3 1/2" M 27-2. See photos. Before I even started the required paper work at my FFL I had a SERIOUS cash offer of $1,600.00 for it. Gave the offer 30 seconds thought and did not sell. Now you know why I'll never be a rich man.
 

Attachments

  • 1.jpg
    1.jpg
    56.9 KB · Views: 144
  • 2.jpg
    2.jpg
    53.9 KB · Views: 129
  • 5.jpg
    5.jpg
    52 KB · Views: 110
  • 3.jpg
    3.jpg
    36.4 KB · Views: 117
Last edited:
As I always say...

1. There are a lot of guys out there with money who don't mind spending it on their hobby. I am not one of them but they exist.

2. Classic guns aren't made any longer. Each year there are fewer available as the number of guys wanting them increases. Supply and demand.

3. Inflation. With $4 gas and a middle priced car at nearly $30K are we really shocked to see a nice Model 19 go for $800? I see beat up 1930s M&Ps in the local shops tagged at $700. Mundane Pythons are SELLING north of 2 grand these days.

4. I am REALLY glad I have my guns because I sure as hell couldn't afford to buy them today. Once in a while I get a pretty good deal on something but it is NOT like the old days.
 
The higher prices start at the 22LR caliber(k22).

The s&w k22. 6" barrel skyrocketing from $595/$1,500+ 99% blued to be worth $1,200 already. With box/accessories pre k22
The s&w m28 HP 6" barrel average $695 +/- blued 99% to me there worth $1,000 already
The s&w m27. 6" barrel average $795 +/- blued 99% to me there worth $1,200 already

This is just my thinking on what the actual prices are now if someone was selling one.


My limit is under $1,000 for used. But to fill a gap I may consider paying a tad more.

You should be happy and cherish dearly what we already have for sure. Your sitting on gold. The higher prices won't change my want list but I may look at the brand new ones first. The high prices will slow down my buying for sure.

I think from the posts here the 357 Magnums are very collectable and highly sought after now. When the offerings slow down and they become harder to find that's when the prices will really soar.

I'm starting to think about a Rossi revolver for a shooter and ccw carry. The s&w prices will soar enough to buy a car. The python prices are there already.

I haven't seen a used colt, ruger, or s&w revolver locally in four decades. Never a one. They just aren't seen or if they were they sold in minutes. The people who purchased them new were hanging on to them.
 
Last edited:
I just ran a search on Gunbroker, and they have a decent looking 586 currently at $400. I also see a lot of model 65 for sale at decent prices, usually $350 and up. They seem to be less popular, probably due to the fixed sights.
 
I was going to say if you think S & W prices are high, check Colt snakes !! My N Frames are not worth anything close to my Snakes.
 
I just ran a search on Gunbroker, and they have a decent looking 586 currently at $400. I also see a lot of model 65 for sale at decent prices, usually $350 and up. They seem to be less popular, probably due to the fixed sights.

Yup...wait to see if they actually land at that price...then see if they meet reserve...then add shipping...then add transfer fees...

Sent from my Samsung "Smarter Than Me Phone" via tapatalk
 
I was going to say if you think S & W prices are high, check Colt snakes !! My N Frames are not worth anything close to my Snakes.

What that proves is Colt guys have more $$$ than sense;). On the other hand we gentlemen who appreciate the classic products produced by Smith and Wesson understand what quality and a good value are all about:).
 
Accompanied a friend to the show here today. He wanted a S&W but he is on a Taurus budget. Found a 586 with some cosmetic wear and non-factory grip but very good otherwise. He got it for $475.

Later on at another table I saw a used 2.5" 686 with medallion combat stocks tagged at $1,550!
 
Was at a local gunshop Friday, they had a model 27 with diamond magna's for $675.00. I just glanced in the case as I was picking up something, I'm still thinking about it. The cylinder release side I saw was in great condition. Heck, for all I know it's a pre-27 :eek:

Repeat to self, I'm not buying anymore guns. Still, you notice I didn't list the location :p
 
Seems to me that most name brand semi auto whiz bang wonderguns used to be pricier than most revolvers. Sure seems like the script has been flipped. Those old-fashioned obsolete revolvers are quite spendy these days.

Sent from my Samsung "Smarter Than Me Phone" via tapatalk
 
I saw a 99% S&W 686 with an eight inch barrel for $600 today at a gunshow that would be in front of me now if the vendor accepted American Express. S&W for now is shifting manufacturing from revolvers to make its M&Ps which are selling much better than wheelguns right now. The deals are out there if you look hard enough at the small dealers and sellers that are under pressure to turn their inventory. We may well look back on the great low revolver prices of today 10 years from now.
 
I am finding no .357 Smiths at local gun stores for what I would come near paying anymore. Most run north of 8 bills. Yes, I know that somebody out there just bought an anib unfired 586 for $300 and actually added money to the offer because they felt sorry for the poor sucker...er...I mean seller. But are average prices where you live running 800 bucks? Any caliber above .38 just seems like it is marked at crazy money prices.

Sent from my Samsung "Smarter Than Me Phone" via tapatalk


You can't buy gas for 19 cents a gallon nor can you purchase milk for $1 a gallon and you are not going to get 22lr for $.02 a round either. Those days are long gone and its time that you and everyone else wake up and acknowledge that simple fact.

If you want an old S&W 357 in good shape you are going to have to pay for it. That is just the way it is. It's not like there are a lot of them floating around if my area is any indication and they just don't make them that way anymore. So if you want a S&W revolver minus that hole in the side you are going to have to pay for it. That's the reality of the situation we all face today. Pay up or do without.
 
Back
Top