.44 Magnum, Pre-model 29

[Dino44]

Today I had some free time. I went on a recon mission to a few favorite LGS. One store had this magnificent example. Serial # S 1677XX. I have reviewed some of the recent threads that have discussed the value of high condition guns. I'm thinking this one is attractive in the mid $4K neighborhood. I would have to tap the retirement account to get this one. If I don't, I will share its location with an interested member. It is remarkably beautiful. The only flaws I see are the minor turn line, small depression on left grip panel in the checkering, and one small spot of freckling near the muzzle also left side. Here is one photo the clerk let me take.

 

[Hair Trigger]

The serial number puts it around 1957, does it have the upper side plate screw? (5 screw gun)The 5th screw started disappearing around SN S167500, so yours is close. SCSW mentions 5 screw guns seen as high as S174000. I would call the gun Good condition, and it has Cokes and the presentation case, but I wouldn't call it worth $4K. It has a significant turn line (it's through the bluing), so it's been shot a fair amount, and the other things you mention also subtract from being better than Good. SCSW calls a Good condition worth $1700 back in 2016 when the 4th Ed was published, so it's probably worth 10-15% more than that now. Certainly it would bring more as a 5 screw than a 4 screw.

Doc44 will certainly give his opinion when he sees the thread, and my opinion is based solely on what I've read; his knowledge on the .44M is unquestioned and based on his experience with them, much better than mine.

 

[Dino44]

The serial number puts it around 1957, does it have the upper side plate screw? (5 screw gun)The 5th screw started disappearing around SN S167500, so yours is close. SCSW mentions 5 screw guns seen as high as S174000. I would call the gun Good condition, and it has Cokes and the presentation case, but I wouldn't call it worth $4K. It has a significant turn line (it's through the bluing), so it's been shot a fair amount, and the other things you mention also subtract from being better than Good. SCSW calls a Good condition worth $1700 back in 2016 when the 4th Ed was published, so it's probably worth 10-15% more than that now. Certainly it would bring more as a 5 screw than a 4 screw.

Doc44 will certainly give his opinion when he sees the thread, and my opinion is based solely on what I've read; his knowledge on the .44M is unquestioned and based on his experience with them, much better than mine.

Yes, Sir it is a five screw. My photo probably does not do it justice. In person the bluing is deep and dark. While I was inspecting it. It drew a crowd of 4 other enthusiasts in the shop and all of them commented on how beautiful it looked. The muzzle still looks near new. The bore and cylinders are shiny and clean. The recoil shield has no discernable wear, and I did not see any flame cutting. It appeared to be fired very little. I do appreciate your input. That is why I posted to get people's opinions.

 

[AC Man]

I can tell you I paid $4,100 hundred for a 1957 lettered 4 screw that looks unfired mint except faint turn line box and tools.

Also paid $4,100 for a 5 screw in equal condition with box and too except it has a 1/8 th scratch above the trigger frame. I have no idea how that could happen, seller did not disclose it either. Both were purchased 2 years ago.

In my humble opinion unless it was mint with a turn line I would not pay over 4K the ones that are mint are around 5K with presentation case. Hell I have seen 29 - 2 sell for over 4K

There is a model 57 41 mag 1964 on Gunbroker for over 4K with several days to go. If I am spending that much money it better look like the gunsmith just handed it over from the factory to the sales department.

 

[Hawg Rider]

That's a beautiful set...what was the asking price at the gun shop or haven't they priced it yet? I'm not sure it's a $4500 revolver, but you guys apparently have much fatter wallets than I do. It is in really nice condition and the presentation case is worth a bunch on it's own. I would think the value would be around $3K, but prices are going crazy for almost all vintage revolvers. Too rich for my blood, but please let us know if you decide to buy this one.

 

[Bald1]

^^^^^^^ yes. What was asking price? If it’s $4k , $3500 would not be an unreasonable offer

 

[22hipower]

The inside of the box looks to be in better condition than many we see. It may have been reconditioned but it appears original to me and if the outside is equally nice it is better than most that I see. If that one was offered in the RIA auctions I've been watching lately $4k plus their 17.5% buyers premium would be a very likely price. If I wanted the gun I think I'd take $4k worth of Benjamins to the LGS and plunk them on the counter. I suspect you'd take it home. Good luck.

Jeff
SWCA #1457

 

[boykinlp]

This may be minor, but ALL part’s value is important when talking about collectibles. Correct me if I’m wrong, but I believe the SAT (screwdriver) and brush are not the right ones.
Larry

 

[22hipower]

This may be minor, but ALL part’s value is important when talking about collectibles. Correct me if I’m wrong, but I believe the SAT (screwdriver) and brush are not the right ones.
Larry

I think most of the 5 screw guns, maybe all of them, shipped with the aluminum SAT and I think the brush should have the brass end but that wouldn't keep me from buying the gun.

Jeff
SWCA #1457

 

[Dino44]

Thank you all for your insightful comments. The revolver is on consignment. It is priced at $4700.00. The box is in very good condition. The only damage I saw was a tear in the cloth, and break in the plastic backing, behind the rear sight. The exterior of the box shows its age but is still very nice. No tears or pealing. The gold logo on top has some fading but is clearly legible. The brass latch and hinges are secure and functional. I did not inspect the bottom. This particular shop is typically open to negotiation when the firearms are theirs. They will present offers to the consignor unless the person has already set a bottom-line price. The gun is a new consignment this past week, so maybe some time may soften the price some. I will keep you all informed.