Could be that the ejector rod has loosened up a bit and pushed the ejector star to the rear where it's lodged against the recoil shield behind the cylinder. If that's the case, tighten the ejector rod by turning counter clock wise until finger tight. If it's loose this will be easy to turn. If that's not it, then look between the rear of the cylinder and the recoil shield and see if the brass is sticking out of the rear of the cylinder. If it is, then there could be something like a lot of powder fouling under the extractor star pushing the star to the rear. If this is the case you are going to have to wiggle it back and forth enough to get the star seated so it will allow you to index the extractor.
Bill