600 bucks

[Burley]

For $600, I can get a 5 screw pre-M28 or a 5 screw pre-M15.

Both 4" barrels

The pre-M28 looks original and the pre-M15 has target hammer and trigger and grips with no diamond.

Is one more desirable? I'm leaning toward the magnum but I also have a little collection of K frames that I'd like to add to.

Also, it's a must buy on Friday deal cause they'll be gone Saturday.

 

[bigggbbruce]

The 28 if it checks out..All day long...

But try to get a better deal... Just me..

 

[delcrossv]

I'd go for the 28.

 

[NYlakesider]

Another for the 28. If you can come up with the money get both, might even get a few bucks off on a double deal!

Happy Buying!

 

[andy52]

Both are outstanding revolvers but 600 seems a little high for a pre 15 unless it is in near new condition with all the goodies.
A shooter grade pre 15 can be had for less then 600.
I find the 15 to be faster on target due to the weight difference, 28s are a little bulky if your just shooting 38s.

 

[CH4]

I'd try and get both, but the 28 if allowed just one. If the 15 were a 2"...

 

[Jack Flash]

It would be nice to have more information.

You say you already have some K-Frames; can we assume one or more of them are .38 Specials?
Same question, .357 Magnums?
Obviously if you haven't got a .357 M, advantage: Pre-28.

Do you want to shoot lighter loads or full-power .357 Mags?
Or all of the above?
Maybe you don't even want to shoot full-power Mags, but if you do, advantage: Pre-28.

One seems to be more original than the other. Of course, being original doesn't mean it isn't all beat up. IE, condition is important. So, advantage: you tell us.

Is carry / concealability important? If so, advantage: pre-15.

Well, I've rambled enough … let us know.

 

[THE PILGRIM]

It's the 28, all day, all the way!

 

[lkabug]

Another vote for the 28. No contest.

 

[Waveski]

Personal preference - two very different firearms.
I tried an N frame for a while , did not take to it. Sold it and added to my K frame group. For recreational shooting and target I prefer .38 sp over 357 anyway.

Like I said ...

 

[Chukar60]

Tough decision.
As you can see there are a lot of N frame fans here.
There are a few of us malcontents here who are not quite as enamored with the N frame.
I love them, but only chambered in cartridges that start with a 4.
If you are concerning yourself with value, I would lean toward the Highway Patrolman.

 

[MixmodelA]

There seems to be far more Pre 15's on the market than Pre 28's. If you can only get one, get the 28. Thanks! Mick

 

[gman51]

Seeing how I bought a 28-2 recently the 28 gets my vote. I believe the end game will go toward the 28 for value.

 

[Valmet]

Another vote for the 28 here...

 

[CapnB]

Both fine guns. I've carried and qualified with them both. The $600 might be closer to a good deal on the Highway Patrolman, but it's all about condition. Oh, and a collection of K frames must contain a Combat Masterpiece. I think there's a rule about it somewhere .
Good shootin',
Doug

 

[dr. mordo]

Pre-28, no question

 

[jay73]

Another vote for the Highway Patrolman. Hope your able to post your new purchase here for us.

 

[BAM-BAM]

While I prefer K and L frames over N-frames......for me .357 trumps .38special as a more versatile gun.... that can also shoot any .38 sp. load.

 

[younggun22]

How come no one has said both?

The answer is ALWAYS both!

 

[Muley Gil]

How come no one has said both?

The answer is ALWAYS both!

You must not have read post #4 and post #6:

"Another for the 28. If you can come up with the money get both, might even get a few bucks off on a double deal!

Happy Buying!"

"I'd try and get both, but the 28 if allowed just one. If the 15 were a 2"..."