Well I have to say it is the fault of all of those who post on this forum about how great the 3rd gen S&W's are. Based on your recommendation, I acquired a 5906 Police trade in from Bud's for $349 with free shipping. The 5906 was as clean as a whistle when I took it apart to clean it and it only needed to be oiled. I cleaned up the sights and brightened the dots with nail polish too. The grip shows some wear and I'll be looking to replace those as soon as I find some new ones. At the range the gun functioned just fine with no issues. The range officer provided me with some advice on the number of pistols a man needs - just one more. I think it will be another 3rd gen...