Colt 1851 Navy.....wish it could talk.

Joined
Jul 18, 2022
Messages
260
Reaction score
1,178
Location
Ohio
Here are a few photos of a Colt 1851 army issued revolver. This Colt Navy has inspector cartouches on both stock panels with all numbers matching, including the wedge, and the small US mark on the left side of the frame above the trigger guard. There are hints of original finish in protected areas and the metal edges are sharp with a good cylinder scene. Timing and lock-up are perfect.

Army issued 1851 Navies are not common but can be found. What makes this one potentially a little more interesting are the three notches in the barrel just forward of the cylinder. They are pretty evenly spaced and of depth so they don't appear to be placed there randomly. I suppose they could be tool marks but that doesn't seem to be the case to me.

Without historical documentation I would not normally put a lot of faith in gun notch stories, but since this revolver was manufactured and issued a short time before the war when both sides were rushing to arm their soldiers, I would say this Colt likely saw a lot of service. That doesn't mean the marks were placed on the barrel during the war, the barrel could have been notched many years later.

Wether the notches indicate something or they are just random dents on a revolver that's 166 years old I will never know, either way I like holding this piece of history in my hands.

If any of you have a neat firearm with tally marks of past hunts or historical interest I would appreciate reading about them.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20240625_131451.jpg
    IMG_20240625_131451.jpg
    124.5 KB · Views: 63
  • IMG_20240625_133305.jpg
    IMG_20240625_133305.jpg
    89.9 KB · Views: 69
  • IMG_20240625_133347.jpg
    IMG_20240625_133347.jpg
    88.5 KB · Views: 59
  • IMG_20240625_133432.jpg
    IMG_20240625_133432.jpg
    86.5 KB · Views: 66
Register to hide this ad
Being older I am sometimes asked what words of wisdom I have to share. My first reply is "write down everything". Things get lost over time. I have many examples of mis- remembered and totally made-up history. Your revolver has the cool factor few things have with apparently zero written history. I have a relic condition H&R top break 32 caliber "ladies muff gun". These were never used for any kind of hunting or target practice, yet mine has 7 similar tally notches filed into the top rib. When tally notches are seen on hunting rifles it can be assumed to be hunting kills but, on our revolvers, it can mean few things. My main hunting rifle has a tally sheet under the butt plate. Your revolver seems much loved and cared for. I had a Winchester model 94 carbine built in 1933 that has only 10% original bluing and no stock finish left, yet the gun looks well taken care of. If only it could tell its tales.
 
Your advice to write down everything is spot on. I've tried to keep good records of historical relics I own. The idea of a tally sheet under a butt plate is excellent!
 
One of my LGS dealer friends, sold a new H&R top break 22 to the local Mail Man (letter carrier) in 1974. He bought it back when the Mail Man retired in 1996. File cut into the trigger guard were 7 notches, so much for the dogs that bite!

In the early 1960's dad owned a SAA in 45 Colt and 7.5" barrel. It was a documented Texas Ranger gun (nobody famous!) it had the hammer filed narrow to conform to a regulation against "Fanning" the hammer, a very nice silver Texas eagle affixed to the butt. And a third modification, 3 notches file cut in the grip frame.

Not all notches denote kills from a gun fight, but they do require real effort and are there to remind the owner of something.

Ivan

I didn't learn of this mail man's gun story until the early 21st century, but I remember that letter carrier as a jerk, that got in fist fights with residents on the route where our office was. This story didn't surprise me one bit!
 
Last edited:
Back
Top