I will openly admit to being a gun snob, but not in a bad way like condoning people for their own preference. I am more a gun snob in the sense that I am very critical on what revolver designs I will own and use.
The Colt V spring action is about the only thing that tickles my fancy. Why? I have always had an engineers mind, and the pocketwatch like intricacy of the Colt action is truly a marvel of design. There is no other action that you can custom tune/tweak to make however you want quite like a Colt V spring. Eliminate the stacking, and I would bet more than one of you would be amazed.
I don't condone the current prices, never have. No reason for it, but everyone sure seems happy to pay them so they exist. However, it is changing daily for the better, and will continue.
Instead of defending the 'weak' Colt action in my normal way, I have a different theory now. Some had experiences that make them think Colt is inferior, others like me had experiences that make them think S&W is inferior, who is right? When it comes to the stronger action design, I think they are both about equal. I don't think that the Colt V spring is inherently weaker, but rather a result from the final hand fitting.
Colt and S&W revolvers are tough shooters that I believe will BOTH last a life time if properly maintained. Properly maintained being the key word. If you get a shotty built gun from the factory, it's not going to last long right? Or if you don't keep your gun properly maintained and in spec, it's not going to last long right?
Based on my experience working on the V spring, almost every single Colt I have come across benefited from me tuning it up and putting it back into spec. Considering this V spring design is all hand fitted parts, they probably all didn't leave the factory perfectly 'built'. Think of the Python, considered a custom built production gun. They surely didn't have the time to perfectly tune them, which they NEED. That is why after the '60s, quality started dropping because the era of hand fitting master smiths was winding down, but the design still called for hand fitting.
So maybe that plays a role in folk's experiences. I know all of my properly tuned Colts are reliable, accurate, and tough as nails. All of my properly tuned Smiths are reliable, accurate, and tough as nails. They are on a more level playing field than most would think. Of course folks will always have their own personal preferences, that won't change. So enjoy what you like, but don't shy away from a Colt because internet lore. You may just end up liking it.