Help please - Model 1905 gen 4?

Joined
Jan 24, 2020
Messages
3
Reaction score
9
Location
Lacey, WA
Hello to Everyone on the forum!

I have recently come across a WWII era S&W revolver, and I spent some hours lurking and researching it on a couple sites. It belonged to my "Step Father in Law". He had owned it a long time I think. He was a Vietnam Vet who recently passed. Tho I have known of it for several years, I know little about the actual provenance.

I will try to attach some decent pics to show what I am trying to describe.

It's a 4in, .38 special, hand ejector per the markings. The revolver serial number is 984103, stamped on the butt, cylinder and barrel, and it appears to have the same SN stamped on the inner right side of the smooth square butt wood grips. The butt swivel is attached.

There is no US Government markings on the top strap of any kind, so I am thinking, Police model instead of Military issue.

It has a fixed notch rear sight and half-moon front blade.

There isn't an obvious "V" marking until you open the cylinder and find the to find the matching (assembly?) numbers (31 361). No "S" at all that I can find. The "V" marking I CAN find is just above the assembly (?) number on the frame, and another "V" near the bottom of the grip - vicinity of the lanyard loop on both sides in slightly different locations. Again, there is no "S" that I can find indicating any updated safety modifications.

There is a stamped "R" also on the bottom right of the grip near the spring notch, and a "2" up high on the right side back strap, both hidden by the wood grips. There is some obvious sanding , or light grinding, where the back strap-ushers into the palm, but that is the only obvious alterations.

The patina isn't great, and appears bluish (depending on the light it can also appear a slightly parkerized brown), rather worn I think, with some small light rust spots visible in various places. The cylinder and barrel appear a little dirty from some past use, but everything seems tight and the trigger seems fairly smooth. Probably could stand a good cleaning and a little trigger lube.

The lack of obvious "V" or "S" near the SN makes me think this is a late model, 1905 gen 4, near the end of the run before they transitioned to the official "Victory" model. If true, perhaps this was shipped mid-to-late '42 to a US Maritime Commission / Defense Supply location? Or is this really a later Victory model with strangely placed "V" stamps?

What I would like to know if, given the pictures, anyone can tell me a little more of the provenance and potential value?

Is it worth being lettered?

I would enjoy it being simply a shooter "as-is", but if there is some reason to preserve it as some sort of collectible then that would be great to know as well.

In advance, from the soggy Pacific NorthWest, thanks!
 

Attachments

  • 7F9A7A2D-1DF0-4850-AAB1-E36B1E3C1BF3.jpeg
    7F9A7A2D-1DF0-4850-AAB1-E36B1E3C1BF3.jpeg
    108.4 KB · Views: 83
  • D224F422-A10D-4312-AAF8-E4411608F21D.jpeg
    D224F422-A10D-4312-AAF8-E4411608F21D.jpeg
    98.8 KB · Views: 83
  • 1EA4FE4C-C6C2-4B9C-A8AC-7C2EF85C6AA1.jpeg
    1EA4FE4C-C6C2-4B9C-A8AC-7C2EF85C6AA1.jpeg
    61 KB · Views: 79
  • A333EABE-EC01-4D75-8011-0900AEE46BAD.jpeg
    A333EABE-EC01-4D75-8011-0900AEE46BAD.jpeg
    52.2 KB · Views: 72
  • CFC7FE63-3114-4E6E-90A5-2F7741667362.jpeg
    CFC7FE63-3114-4E6E-90A5-2F7741667362.jpeg
    61.6 KB · Views: 56
Register to hide this ad
Help Please - Model 1905 gen 4? (More pics)

Here are some additional pictures, hope this helps.

Thanks again!
 

Attachments

  • 4EB77882-7F7B-42F4-8A3D-9C4C0E970202.jpeg
    4EB77882-7F7B-42F4-8A3D-9C4C0E970202.jpeg
    82.8 KB · Views: 45
  • A3328EF3-4BCF-4CF6-866C-8721D3D18871.jpeg
    A3328EF3-4BCF-4CF6-866C-8721D3D18871.jpeg
    87.1 KB · Views: 45
  • 1032FABE-A59A-48C1-BF4C-C82AC0C9CE2C.jpeg
    1032FABE-A59A-48C1-BF4C-C82AC0C9CE2C.jpeg
    73.3 KB · Views: 46
  • A83F9862-8B1F-41DC-A005-D88A339DB0CC.jpeg
    A83F9862-8B1F-41DC-A005-D88A339DB0CC.jpeg
    51.8 KB · Views: 47
  • 7D589953-67B4-405B-BADB-8C63FE627C52.jpeg
    7D589953-67B4-405B-BADB-8C63FE627C52.jpeg
    65.6 KB · Views: 47
Welcome to the Forum.

Your revolver is known as a pre Victory or as a .38 Military & Police. It was built around 1941-1942. One of our collectors will be along soon to narrow the date down.

While this revolver is in nice shape, you won't hurt it by shooting it.
 
Last edited:
Welcome! Good information above. The photos suggest the original finish was "brush (matte) blue", which would be appropriate for some guns of that era.

It likely shipped in early 1942 and by that time the Defense Services Corporation was allocating production of all new small arms. With this it very likely went to a defense related (including law enforcement) destination, since it has no military acceptance marks. There is a recent thread with a discussion about a similar gun:

Commercial Post War Victory with no Hammer Block. What is it?

The V and other small stampings are likely assembler, fitter or inspector marks, not related to it being a Victory model (since those had the V serial number prefix).

Finally, a letter of authenticity would let you know its ship date and destination:

http://www.swhistoricalfoundation.com/swhf_letter.pdf

Hope this is helpful.
 
First I would like to offer my condolences on the passing of your father-in-law. With every veteran lost we lose a lot of oral history.

Your revolver was likely shipped in the March-June, 1942 time frame and looks to have survived in reasonably good condition. You may want to obtain a S&W historical letter as some of the Defense Supply Corp. guns had interesting destinations.
 
Nice revolver you have taken in. Shoot and enjoy.
I am constantly reminded how much I enjoy reading the information that flows in so quickly from so many knowledgeable people here.
 
The closest SN I have on my list to your 984103 is 983276 which shipped on 5/15/42 (that one went to the U. S. Navy). Without any property stampings, there is a very high probability it is a DSC gun. Whether it is worth spending $100 for a letter is your choice. I probably wouldn't.
 
.....
The patina isn't great, and appears bluish (depending on the light it can also appear a slightly parkerized brown), rather worn I think, ........

Victory finishes are notoriously hard to photograph well. Artificial light does not help.

But the finish on this gun isn't very worn, nor is there any patina. Except for those specks of red you mentioned, some corner wear, and a strange shadow line on the cylinder possibly from storage (see arrow), this appears to be an original Sandblast Black Magic, the standard Victory finish throughout the war, in very good condition.

Below yours I added a picture of an as-new, likely unissued Victory. It did look that ugly from the factory ;)

PS: Get a letter.

attachment.php


attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • pre v.jpg
    pre v.jpg
    81.9 KB · Views: 55
  • vic0.JPG
    vic0.JPG
    47.3 KB · Views: 55
Absalom, ChiefDave, DWalt, all -

Thanks so much for the condolences, information and confirmations.

Both my Dad & StepDad were Vietnam Era vets, and enjoyed shooting tremendously. I grew up doing same and my career spanned across Desert Storm & early OIF years. So, being the "caretaker" of this shooter makes it kind of special, and shooting it will be a wonderful re-connection to them and to the Greatest Generation too.

I may indeed get it lettered, just to see where it might have gone. If so, I will share any details for the group and database.

Thanks again.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top